Turn manuscript issues into concrete revision actions
These scenarios do not represent real authors, institutions, or journals and do not imply acceptance. They illustrate how reports connect issues, evidence, and recommendations.
CASE WALKTHROUGH
One case, four steps
Problem excerpt, evidence, recommendation and author decision sit on one card so the revision can be checked against them.
Problem excerpt
The conclusion states that the intervention applies to all age groups.
Evidence
All participants were 18–30, and the discussion does not flag the limits of extrapolation.
Recommendation
Scope the conclusion to the sample, or list what extrapolation would require in the discussion.
Author decision
Accepted the narrower wording and added the sample range to limitations.
The case is prototype demo data. No real submission is used and no acceptance outcome is claimed.
REVIEW SCENARIOS
Different manuscripts require different evidence chains
- Empirical study · Significant result without practical effect
- Add effect sizes and 95% confidence intervals, and distinguish statistical from practical significance.
- Review article · Search scope does not support the conclusion
- Document the search strategy and limitations, and narrow claims that exceed the evidence.
- Methods paper · Reproduction parameters are incomplete
- Add parameter tables, software versions, and control conditions, and state reproducibility limits.
- Thesis · Chapter conclusions do not support the central argument
- Map the research questions, chapter findings, and final contributions.
REVISION PRIORITY
Address credibility risks first
- Must fix
- Issues that directly affect methodological reliability, evidence boundaries, or core conclusions.
- Suggested
- Issues affecting completeness, reproducibility, or clarity of argument.
- Optional improvement
- Changes that improve expression, structure, and reading experience.